Campfire vs Slack
Both are web-based team chat with rooms, direct messages, file attachments, and mobile access. The key difference is pricing model: Slack charges per active user each month, while Campfire is a self-hosted install with no ongoing subscription.
| Feature | Campfire | Slack |
|---|
| License | MIT | Proprietary |
| Pricing | Free (self-hosted) | Per-seat subscription |
| Self-hosting | Yes | No |
| Mobile | PWA | Native apps (iOS/Android) |
| App integrations | HTTP API | Extensive marketplace |
| Data location | Your server | Slack's cloud |
Campfire is the better choice when your team wants to eliminate recurring messaging costs and does not depend on Slack's integration marketplace. It covers basic chat without the complexity Slack has added over the years, and your message history stays on your own infrastructure. Slack is worth considering when native iOS/Android apps are required, or when your workflows depend on first-party integrations with Jira, Salesforce, GitHub, or similar services that Campfire's HTTP API cannot replicate without custom development.
Campfire vs Basecamp
Campfire and Basecamp are both from 37signals. Basecamp is a full project management and team communication platform; Campfire is a standalone group chat application. Where Basecamp bundles messaging alongside to-dos, file storage, schedules, and check-ins under a subscription, Campfire is chat only, free to self-host, and MIT-licensed.
| Feature | Campfire | Basecamp |
|---|
| License | MIT | Proprietary |
| Pricing | Free (self-hosted) | Per-team subscription |
| Self-hosting | Yes | No |
| Scope | Chat only | Chat, tasks, files, schedules |
| Data location | Your server | Basecamp's cloud |
| Mobile | PWA | Native apps (iOS/Android) |
Campfire is the right choice for teams that need only self-hosted chat and want to avoid a broader project management subscription. Teams already paying for Basecamp get messaging as part of the bundle; running Campfire alongside it only makes sense when on-premises message storage or data ownership is a hard requirement. Teams that rely on Basecamp's project management features (to-dos, check-ins, file storage, milestones) will not find them in Campfire.