Tidemark vs Fathom Analytics
Fathom Analytics is a fully managed service starting at $14 a month for 100,000 monthly pageviews. It requires no setup. Add a script, sign up, and the dashboard appears. Tidemark's self-hosted tier covers the same cookie-free, single-page analytics model for the cost of a PHP host, under an MIT license with no monthly fees. The tradeoff is operational responsibility. Fathom handles uptime, backups, and updates; Tidemark self-hosted puts that on you, though the in-app updater reduces the maintenance burden.
Fathom is the right choice for teams with no server to spare and a budget for monthly SaaS fees, or who need a proven long-term track record and direct support. Tidemark wins for site owners on PHP shared hosting who cannot or will not pay recurring fees, who want full data ownership, or who need a Plausible-compatible API.
Tidemark vs Cloudflare Web Analytics
Cloudflare Web Analytics is free, requires no server, and sets no cookies. It collects pageview data at the network edge. The main limitation is data portability. Cloudflare provides no CSV export, no Stats API, no custom goals, and no way to move your data off Cloudflare. It is a read-only view of Cloudflare's collection.
Tidemark owns your data. You can export every visit and event as CSV, query the Stats API with any filter, and move your database to a different host at any time. For site owners whose analytics needs exceed a simple traffic count, Tidemark's exportability and goal tracking are concrete advantages over Cloudflare's free-but-locked offering.
Tidemark vs Simple Analytics
Simple Analytics is a privacy-first hosted service with per-site pricing. Plans start around $9 a month for smaller sites. Like Fathom, it is fully managed with no self-hosted option.
Tidemark's self-hosted tier is the key distinction. Once deployed, there is no per-month cost, the source is fully accessible, and the Plausible-compatible API means your existing event instrumentation continues to work. Simple Analytics wins on simplicity and low setup friction; Tidemark wins for site owners who want to self-host, avoid subscription costs, and run on existing PHP hosting.